Weaknesses of the new law and risks for the owners of the LLC

A new law on limited liability companies and additional liability dated February 6, 2018, № 2275-VIII will come into force on June 17, 2018. Besides the wide opportunities for founders of companies, the law may have negative consequences.

We have already written about the main news of the law here.

Now, we want to focus on possible negative consequences and risks that the law may bring.

Of course, it is difficult to predict the regulatory impact of a law that has not yet entered into force. However, it is necessary to calculate the possible risks and methods of protection.

One of the main issues causes a different assessment is the reduction of the list of mandatory information in the company’s charter. The new law requires the charter to specify only the name (full and abbreviated), the list of authorities (their authority and procedure for making decisions), as well as the procedure of joining and withdrawal.
The list of participants and the size of their shares will no longer be specified in the charter.

This allows specify a minimum information and simplifies the procedure for changing the details of a legal entity. It will not be necessary to approve the new edition of the statute every time.

According to some experts, the narrowing of the list of mandatory information allows us to include in charter disputed provisions that can be used by unscrupulous business partners in the future to seize control over the company.

Ambiguous assessment is caused by corporate agreements, which do not require notarization and are vulnerable to falsification.

In addition, the new law does not require notifying the company about the conclusion of such an agreement.
Irrevocable power of attorney – another innovation, which can have risky consequences. It has already been provided by current legislation and remains in a new law. If something goes wrong, canceling of such power of attorney is impossible.

The new law does not sufficiently regulate the procedure for the withdrawal of a participant who has less than 50% in the authorized capital. Thus, the law states that there is no need to obtain an agreement of general meeting. The participant is deemed to have withdrawn since the state registration of the changes.

Accordingly, if a participant lodges an application for a state registrar, there will be no grounds for a refusal to register the actions under the new law. However, it is not clear how to reduce the share capital and pay the share value.

If the state registrar refuses to register, will it be legitimate?

The above procedure may be detailed in the company’s charter, however all known cases of “rewriting” of the law in the statute. Therefore, there are no guarantees of a sufficient settlement of this issue.

Since LLC is one of the most widespread forms of business in Ukraine, innovations and legal risks will have a significant impact on the activities of such legal entities.

It is important for the founders of the companies to be attentive in the new legislative realities and not to neglect the services of lawyers when drafting the statute, making changes to it and preparing other documents.

Whether the new law will become a step forward in improving business or cause more threats and raider hunts will show time.

Nevertheless, it is better not to make a charter in terms of maximum protection from conflicts in the future, to consolidate clear terms it in, to analyze in detail the corporate agreements and to certify them at a notary office.

The fee for the qualitative preparation of documents and their notary certification is nothing against those risks of negligence when registering your business. In the future, more and more money will be spent on protecting your rights and legitimate interests in the courts.

Our Lawyers can make qualitative preparation of documents for business registration taking into account all your wishes. This will help you to avoid ambiguity in the constituent documents and minimize conflicts between founders in the future.

Weaknesses of the new law and risks for the owners of the LLC
You may like
A new law on virtual assets: the picture is formed, but without details. On September 8, 2021, the Verkhovna Rada has finally adopted the long-awaited law "On Virtual Assets", which clarified many ambiguous points. This is especially true for the status of cryptocurrency and the rules of its circulation in the country. Let`s take a closer look at novelties. An ambiguous term Let's start with what the legislator actually means by "virtual assets". There are the following features:  they are an intangible good (cannot be represented on tangible media)  fall under the list of objects of civil rights (that is, they can be owned and be disposed of)  represent an electronic form of a set of data (essentially, they are blocks of information put in order);  the existence and circulation of assets are due to software tools (specific electronic environment). From these features we can draw the following conclusion: virtual assets are not limited to cryptocurrency. Digital currency is part of the concept, but other instruments, such as tokens, NFTs, or even in-game items, fall under the definition. Actually, the actual existence of most digital products, having a certain value, is due to the software environment (ecosystem), either it is blockchain technology, a trading platform, or an online game server. It should be noted that the attempt to define virtual assets was already made in the adopted Law of Ukraine in counteracting money laundering. In this act, they understand it as digital means of payment, which goes against the new definition. As a result, there are now two different explanations for virtual assets, which causes significant confusion not only in regulation but also in interpretation. It is definitely necessary to expect clarifications from competent state bodies. Let's return to the new law. Its application covers legal relations in which the "Ukrainian element" is present:  provider or recipient of services represented in Ukraine;  an agreement according to which the turnover of virtual assets is carried out in accordance with Ukrainian legislation;  the acquirer of assets (or both counterparties) is a resident(s) of Ukraine. The law also introduces an interesting division of all virtual assets into two groups: secured and unsecured. Here again, there is a problem of interpretation. The first category includes products exchanged for (state) currency, the second category includes instruments that can be exchanged only for other digital assets. There is an alternative opinion: that the turnover of secured assets is supported by real goods (money or other property), while unsecured ones are not supported by anything. The latter interpretation is the most credible, as the new law stipulates that virtual assets are NOT means of payment. Moreover, they cannot be exchanged for real goods, be they property, services or money. This significantly narrows the potential for the use of virtual assets not only for commercial but also for civilian purposes. About obligatory licensing The new law states that in some cases, the use of virtual assets will require licensing. The 4 types of activity are mentioned:  storage and management of virtual assets (or its` keys)  servicing of exchange operations with virtual assets (both for other analogues and for real goods);  translation of digital assets;  any intermediary services. A list is quite impressive, but there are some important exclusions:  if your service works with cryptocurrency wallet (it means users can dispose of accumulations into cryptocurrency independently);  If your service works on smart contracts or decentralized protocol, based on which internal transfers are performed. As to intermediary services, everything is more compicated. Actually, any mediation is based on the public share offering. That is why it is subject to licensing. How to get a license? A company that wishes on legal grounds to engage in virtual assets must satisfy legislative requirements. The key role is played by the minimum amount of the statutory capital, which equals 1,19 million hryvnyas (for non-residents it is 5,95 million hryvnyas) in case of storage and administration. For other types of activity (trading, translation and mediation services) the minimum size of the statutory capital amounts to 595 thousand hryvnyas (for non-residents is 2,98 million hryvnyas). The order of the registration of license:  to compose an application and prepare documents.  to pay state fee (68-136 thousand hryvnyas for residents and 340-680 thousand hryvnyas is for non-residents).  to pend review of the request (30 days).  to get a license. The duration of the license is 1 year. No norms about the continuation of legal force of permission are set (we are expecting amendments or explanations from the Ministry of Digital transformation of Ukraine). Notably that non-residents must pay a far greater sum, than domestic companies. The Ukrainian legislator obviously encourages an internal market, getting rid of a strong foreign presence (that, in fact, coincide with modern politics of the state on the whole). Together with an application, the following documents must be prepared: The access code to the copy of the Statute of the company (or the foundation agreement) kept in an electronic file in the database of the Unified State Register of Enterprises and Organizations (USREO);  Funding sources of the statutory capital (where the money are taken from);  confirmation of the actual injection of money;  information about beneficiaries (special attention must be paid to business reputation);  the information about the director and founders;  the check about payment of state fee;  the internal regulations, in accordance with which ones, the privacy policy rules are regulated. In the terms of volume of necessary documentation of licensing is very alike with complete registration of legal entity. It is understood that the state wants the severe adjusting of activity of organizations that will engage in virtual assets. Is it already possible to get a license? The adoption of the law by the parliament is a significant step forward in adjusting and legal market of virtual assets creation in Ukraine. However, the new rules haven`t come into effect yet - their term of introduction depends on making amendments in the Internal Revenue Code. It is yet unknown, when a legislator will decide to enter the renewed system of taxation for such assets. Being "IT-hub" and territory, where cryptocurrency enjoys large popularity, the question of taxes must be decided maximally safely. Despite the presence of obvious gaps in interpretation, a new law on virtual assets gives the official narrative of what takes place and that, how the legal relationships related to cryptocurrency will be regulated. It is to be hoped that in the nearest time the Ministry of digital information will give out the detailed explanations concerning debatable norms.

We will
call you